This post may contain affiliate links. If you sign up through one of my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend tools I genuinely believe can help your practice

If you’re comparing Healthie vs. SimplePractice, both platforms can help you manage a private practice, but they’re built with somewhat different types of providers in mind.

SimplePractice is particularly well established among therapists and mental health practices, with a strong focus on clinical documentation, insurance billing, scheduling, telehealth, and practice management.

Healthie takes a more engagement-focused approach, combining electronic health records with scheduling, billing, telehealth, client communication, programs, and tools designed to support ongoing client interaction.

So which one is better?

For a traditional mental health private practice, SimplePractice is likely the better fit for most therapists. But Healthie may be worth considering if you want a more interactive client experience, run programs or memberships, or work across nutrition, wellness, and behavioral health.

Let’s compare Healthie vs. SimplePractice feature by feature so you can decide which makes more sense for your practice.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice at a Glance

Feature	Healthie	SimplePractice
Mental health practices	Good	Excellent
Nutrition practices	Excellent	Good
Clinical documentation	Yes	Yes
Customizable templates	Yes	Yes
Insurance billing	Yes	Yes
Client portal	Yes	Yes
Telehealth	Yes	Yes
Online scheduling	Yes	Yes
Client messaging	Yes	Yes
Appointment reminders	Yes	Yes
Digital forms	Yes	Yes
Group programs	Strong	More limited
Membership-style services	Strong	More limited
Practice management	Strong	Strong
Best suited for	Wellness, nutrition, multidisciplinary practices	Therapists and mental health practices

Features and pricing can change, so verify current plan details before choosing a platform.

What Is Healthie?

Healthie is a healthcare technology platform originally built with nutrition and wellness providers in mind.

The platform combines many of the tools you’d expect from an EHR and practice-management system, including:

• Electronic health records
• Clinical documentation
• Scheduling
• Online intake forms
• Telehealth
• Secure messaging
• Billing and payments
• Client portal
• Appointment reminders
• Care plans
• Client engagement tools
• Programs and group-based services

One of Healthie’s biggest differentiators is its emphasis on client engagement between appointments.

That can make it particularly interesting for providers whose business model involves more than traditional one-on-one appointments.

For example, a practice might use Healthie to support individual sessions alongside educational programs, packages, group offerings, or ongoing client communication.

If your practice leans toward nutrition, wellness, or ongoing client programs rather than a traditional therapy caseload, it’s worth seeing what Healthie can do. Take a look at Healthie.

What Is SimplePractice?

SimplePractice is an EHR and practice-management platform widely used by therapists, behavioral health professionals, and other health and wellness providers.

Its core features include:

• Clinical notes
• Customizable documentation templates
• Scheduling
• Online appointment requests
• Insurance billing
• Claims management
• Client portal
• Secure messaging
• Digital intake forms
• Telehealth
• Payment processing
• Appointment reminders
• Practice analytics and reports

For therapists who primarily need a system to document sessions, schedule clients, submit claims, collect payments, and manage their practice, SimplePractice is a very natural fit.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: EHR and Documentation

Both platforms provide electronic health record functionality, but the overall experience is somewhat different.

SimplePractice has long been focused on clinical documentation for behavioral health and other private-practice providers.

That makes it especially appealing if your workflow revolves around:

1. Seeing a client
2. Completing a clinical note
3. Scheduling the next appointment
4. Billing insurance
5. Tracking payments and claims

Healthie also offers clinical documentation and customizable templates, but its broader ecosystem is designed around ongoing client engagement.

Winner: SimplePractice

For a therapist primarily looking for a traditional mental health EHR, I’d give SimplePractice the edge.

Healthie becomes more compelling if your practice combines clinical services with programs, education, nutrition, wellness, or other ongoing services.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Customizable Notes

Documentation flexibility matters more than many therapists realize.

Your EHR isn’t just where you store notes. Your templates determine how much time you spend documenting after every appointment.

Both Healthie and SimplePractice allow providers to customize their documentation workflows.

SimplePractice is particularly attractive if you want to create templates that reflect your specific clinical workflow rather than relying exclusively on generic note formats.

If customizable documentation is one of your top priorities, I’d recommend testing both platforms before committing.

Winner: SimplePractice

For a traditional therapy practice, SimplePractice gets the edge for documentation.

If you’re interested in customizable note templates specifically, you may also want to compare:

• SimplePractice
• TherapyNotes
• Sessions Health
• TherapyZen
• Jane

The “best” option ultimately depends on how much control you want over your documentation workflow.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Insurance Billing

If you accept insurance, billing functionality becomes a much bigger consideration.

Both platforms offer tools designed to support insurance billing, but your experience will depend on factors such as:

• Which insurance companies you bill
• Whether you submit claims electronically
• Whether you have a biller
• How you handle claim follow-up
• Whether you need detailed reporting
• How you manage patient balances
• Whether you’re participating with insurance networks

SimplePractice has a particularly strong fit for therapists whose practices revolve around insurance-based billing.

That’s important because your EHR doesn’t operate in isolation.

Your billing workflow may include:

Credentialing → eligibility verification → documentation → claim submission → ERA/payment posting → denial management → patient balances → reporting

The easier your EHR makes that workflow, the less manual work you’ll have to do.

Winner: SimplePractice

For an insurance-based mental health practice, SimplePractice would be my first choice between these two.

That doesn’t mean Healthie can’t handle insurance billing. It means SimplePractice fits the typical therapist billing workflow extremely well.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Telehealth

Both platforms offer telehealth functionality, allowing providers to conduct virtual appointments without necessarily piecing together a separate technology stack.

That’s useful because your EHR can keep your:

• Appointment
• Client information
• Documentation
• Communication
• Telehealth session

within the same general workflow.

Telehealth is worth a closer look on its own. If you want to compare more than just these two, 8 Best Telehealth Platforms for Therapists covers the full lineup of options.

Winner: Tie

For basic telehealth needs, either platform can be a reasonable choice.

I’d look at the details of each platform’s current telehealth offering rather than choosing an EHR based solely on whether telehealth is available.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Client Portal

Both Healthie and SimplePractice provide client-facing functionality.

A good client portal can allow clients to do things such as:

• Complete intake paperwork
• View appointments
• Communicate securely
• Access documents
• Make payments
• Participate in aspects of their care

Healthie puts a particularly strong emphasis on the client experience.

That can be valuable if you’re trying to create an ongoing digital relationship with clients rather than simply providing appointments.

Winner: Healthie

I’d give Healthie the edge if client engagement is a major priority.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Scheduling

Both platforms provide online scheduling and appointment-management tools.

For a traditional therapy practice, you probably don’t need an especially complicated scheduling system.

You need clients to be able to:

• Request or book appointments
• Receive reminders
• Complete paperwork
• Attend the appointment
• Reschedule when appropriate

Both platforms can support this type of workflow.

Winner: Tie

This isn’t an area where I’d make my decision between Healthie and SimplePractice.

Instead, look at the scheduling rules you actually need.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Client Engagement

This is where the comparison gets more interesting.

Healthie’s platform is designed to support engagement beyond the traditional appointment.

Depending on your practice model, that can include programs, educational content, messaging, and other ways of interacting with clients between visits.

SimplePractice is more centered around the core practice-management workflow.

That’s not necessarily a disadvantage.

For many therapists, less complexity is actually a benefit.

If you simply want to see clients, document sessions, bill insurance, and get paid, you may not need a platform built around extensive client engagement.

Winner: Healthie

Healthie is the stronger choice if you’re intentionally building a more interactive or program-based client experience.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Ease of Use

Ease of use is highly subjective, especially with EHR software.

A platform can have dozens of features you never use, while another might have exactly what you need without making you dig through unnecessary functionality.

For a therapist who wants a straightforward practice-management system, SimplePractice has a strong advantage because its workflow is closely aligned with the needs of private-practice clinicians.

Healthie may make more sense if you actually plan to use its broader engagement and program capabilities.

Winner: SimplePractice for traditional therapy practices

Healthie wins for flexibility around more complex client-engagement models.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice Pricing

Pricing should be part of your decision, but I wouldn’t choose between these platforms based on the monthly subscription alone.

Instead, calculate your total cost of running the practice.

Consider:

• Monthly EHR fee
• Additional clinician fees
• Billing fees
• Payment processing
• Insurance claim fees
• Telehealth costs
• Add-on features
• Client communication costs
• Other software you’ll need

A platform that costs slightly more but eliminates two other subscriptions could ultimately be less expensive.

Because pricing and plan features can change, check the current pricing pages for both platforms before making a decision.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Which Is Better for a Solo Therapist?

If you’re a solo therapist running a relatively traditional private practice, I’d lean toward SimplePractice.

It’s particularly well-suited to a workflow that looks like:

Schedule → intake → appointment → documentation → claim → payment → next appointment

You don’t necessarily need a platform with extensive program and engagement functionality if your primary service is one-on-one therapy.

Still weighing your options? SimplePractice vs Jane breaks down another popular matchup, so you can see how SimplePractice holds up against a different competitor before you commit.

Which Is Better for a Nutritionist or Wellness Practice?

This is where I’d seriously consider Healthie.

If your practice involves:

• Nutrition counseling
• Wellness programs
• Packages
• Group programs
• Educational content
• Ongoing client engagement
• Multiple types of services

Healthie’s broader approach may be a better match.

In other words, the question isn’t simply “Which EHR has more features?”

It’s:

“Which platform matches the way I actually deliver services?”

Curious whether Healthie fits your specific setup? See Healthie’s plans and features and decide for yourself.

Which Is Better for an Insurance-Based Therapist?

For an insurance-based therapist, I’d choose SimplePractice between these two.

Insurance billing adds complexity to an already busy practice.

Your software needs to support the administrative side of your business without making documentation and billing more cumbersome.

SimplePractice is a strong option if insurance claims are a significant part of your revenue cycle.

That said, don’t choose an EHR solely because it supports claims. Look at the entire billing workflow.

For example, can you easily find:

• Unpaid claims?
• Rejected claims?
• Patient balances?
• Insurance payments?
• Outstanding accounts receivable?
• Billing reports?

These details matter much more once you’re handling dozens or hundreds of claims.

Handling insurance claims day in and day out gets a lot easier with the right system behind you. Check out SimplePractice and see if it fits your billing workflow.

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Pros and Cons

Healthie Pros

• Strong client engagement tools
• Excellent fit for nutrition and wellness practices
• Supports clinical documentation
• Scheduling and telehealth
• Client portal
• Billing and payments
• Useful for programs and ongoing services
• Good option for multidisciplinary practices

Healthie Cons

• May offer more functionality than a traditional therapist needs
• Can be less focused on the standard mental health private-practice workflow
• May not be the best fit if insurance billing is the center of your practice

SimplePractice Pros

• Strong fit for therapists
• Comprehensive practice-management tools
• Clinical documentation
• Customizable templates
• Insurance billing
• Telehealth
• Scheduling
• Client portal
• Secure communication
• Strong reporting capabilities

SimplePractice Cons

• Some advanced functionality may require higher-tier plans or additional fees
• May be more than you need if you’re running a very simple cash-pay practice
• Less focused on program/membership-style client engagement than Healthie

Healthie vs. SimplePractice: Which Should You Choose?

There’s no universal winner.

Choose SimplePractice if you’re a therapist who wants a comprehensive EHR and practice-management system built around clinical documentation, scheduling, insurance billing, and the day-to-day operation of a private practice.

Choose Healthie if you want a more engagement-focused platform and your practice includes nutrition, wellness, programs, education, or services that extend beyond traditional one-on-one appointments.

For most traditional mental health private practices, I’d start with SimplePractice.

For a practice where client engagement and ongoing programs are central to the business model, Healthie deserves a closer look.

And before you commit, take advantage of demos or trials whenever they’re available. The best EHR on paper isn’t necessarily the best EHR once you’re actually using it to document sessions and run your billing workflow.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

For most therapists: SimplePractice.

For nutrition, wellness, and engagement-focused practices: Healthie.

The biggest mistake is choosing an EHR based on a feature checklist alone. Instead, map out your actual workflow and choose the platform that makes your clinical and administrative work easier—not more complicated.